If you don't want to have them set as separate webserver sites (i.e. virtual hosts) then you can actually create a single certificate for all domains and subdomains! All you need to do is put them all on the one line of confconsole.domains.txt. E.g.:
root@lamp ~# cat /etc/dehydrated/confconsole.domains.txt
# please use this file with confconsole or
# alternatively use dehydrated with it's appropriate
# configuration directly
jeremydavis.org lamp.jeremydavis.org lamp-tester.tklapp.com
And here is the certs directory (but this time they're all written to /etc/ssl/private). Note that I deleted all the directories that were there initially so this is new for this run of dehyrdated-wrapper.
Oh, and one more thing...